As gardeners we’re always told to mulch our gardens, but why? Why should we invest so much time and money on mulch? What is the best type of mulch to use, and are all mulches created equal?
Read on as we answer these questions, plus a bunch more as we cover the basics of mulching.
What is mulch?
This is actually less clear-cut than you might think. Generally, mulch refers to any non-living thing that covers bare soil (when I say non-living, I mean in its current state, so not a ground covering plant). So technically, mulch can include anything that is thrown onto bare soil to cover it.
Commonly speaking though, mulch relates to organic coverings like wood chips, leaf litter, grass clippings and straw, but can also include inorganic covers like rocks and pebbles, plastic matting, or sand.
Personally, when I talk about mulch at work, and to clients, I’m only referring to the organic side of things, and I think this is a pretty common view point for most horticulturalist. Hard landscapers on the other hand are the ones who I find to be more inclined to include those inorganic types.
Organic mulch refers to coverings that were once alive and will break down over time. This is by far the most popular type of mulch, and is more than not the left over by-product of a separate gardening task. Woodchips, grass clippings and leaf litter are the most popular recycled mulch products, but products like straw, sugarcane and hemp mulch also fall into this category.
Each type of organic mulch will breakdown at different rates, and return the bulk of their nutrients back to the ecosystem in and around your plants and soils.
These are products that are designed for long term coverage of an area, and will not break down over time. Sand beds, gravel, pebbles and plastic weed matting are popular examples. These are generally more concerned with completely suppressing any plant growth and aesthetics over anything else.
The grey area.
Whilst technically organic, chemically treated hard wood chips are available as mulch and these are extremely long lasting and designed not to break down over time like traditional organic mulch. A lot of the time they also contain artificial dye for colouring which also aids in limiting sun damage, further extending their lifespan.
Whilst not truly inorganic, they fit better in that category, based upon their benefits and problems.
Why do we mulch?
There’s a load of different reasons why we throw mulch onto a garden, and different types of mulch have different benefits associated with it. By no means is mulching a one size fits all approach, so before deciding upon your mulch type, you need to decide what you’re trying to achieve.
Probably the number 1 reason we mulch is to keep down unwanted plants. Seeds are pretty tough little things, and they’ve evolved to fight their way up through soil to the surface, which is no easy task. BUT their energy supplies are limited, so if we add an extra hurdle for them to get past, then they’re more likely to run out of energy, and die off before reaching the surface. A good thick layer of mulch is the perfect extra hurdle. By smothering the soil with a thick layer, we can suppress any weed seeds that want to grow up through, and therefore limit weeds.
Both organic and inorganic mulches will help suppress weeds, but for complete suppression, the winner is inorganic, because they don’t break down over time.
As organic mulches, like grass clippings that form a thick matted layer, break down they essentially create new soil, and are the perfect spot for weed seeds to settle and germinate. This is why we need to continuously top up organic mulched areas, to cover up each generation of weed seeds that make their way into your garden.
The second most common reason we mulch is to conserve moisture levels in our soil.
Bare soil in summer will dry out up to 70% quicker than covered soil, and that’s not good news plants in your garden. A hot day on an un-mulched garden can wreak havoc on your plants, even if you’ve watered them. By covering up the soil with mulch, the sun and heat has an extra layer to penetrate before getting to the moist soil around your plant roots, which can literally save your garden in summer.
It’s really important to note here though that you can put too much mulch on your garden, and actually stop water getting into your soil.
Thick clumping mulches like grass clippings and older straw mulches can form a barrier and restrict water movement downwards, whereas porous mulches like wood chip and gravel will let more get through.
As organic mulches break down, they return their nutrients to all the micro-organisms in and around the soils and your plants. Organic mulches also provide habitat and food for all the little critters in your garden, and can boost the ecology of your backyard. This is great if you’re growing a crop for food or for flowers, as good soil is the foundation of good farming.
Using a quick decomposing mulch like straw, sugar cane or hemp mulch allows you to till your garden each season and provides essential organic matter each time you plant a new crop.
Other organic mulches also aid your soil by acting as a cushion for your soil, protecting against compaction via feet or vehicles, and can keep your soil warm during winter, preventing frosts and freezing.
Inorganic mulches can actually harm your soil more than improve it, by causing compaction and restricting oxygen flows. This isn’t a problem for all plants, but for a high turnover, high yield garden, inorganic mulches are simply no good for soil improvements.
Mulch simply looks better than bare soil. It’s a pretty easy concept, and really changes up a landscape.
Different mulches can provide colours and textures for contrast or compliments, and can even be a garden feature itself, such as a raked sand or pebble garden. Mulch can provide sensory aspects to your garden, like crunching of gravel, or the smell of fresh eucalyptus wood chip.
Which is best for you?
If you’ve followed everything you’ve read so far, you’ll know that the right mulch is going to depend on the situation. Sometimes your preferred choice might not tick all the boxes that you need, and sometimes you might need to make some sacrifices. Below is a summary of the most common types of mulch available, and the pro’s and con’s of each.
Chipped remains of trees, branches and leaves. Come in a variety of sizes and qualities, ranging from roughly chipped arborist leftovers, through to horticultural grade nursery products.
– As they break down they will add organic matter to your soil, and provide habitat and food for microorganisms.
– Easy and cheap to find and install.
– Suppress weeds and retain moisture.
– Products like ‘Forest Fines’ and ‘Hortgrade’ have amazing visual appeal.
– Larger chips can be hard to incorporate into soil during tilling.
– Need topping up every season to continue to work.
– Easily washed away in heavy rains.
– Can transport weed seeds and viable cuttings for vegetative growth into your garden.
A light weight organic product cut up from the plant it has come from. It can quite often be organically produced, and can come in small to large bales.
– Quick break down which adds nutrients to the soil and food for microorganisms.
– Easily worked back into the soil when replaced.
– Suppresses weeds and retains moisture.
– Quick breakdown means regular replacing.
– Easily blow away in high winds.
– Can make an area look a little bit like a farm.
Your leftovers after you mow your lawn. High water content and super quick breaking down.
– About as cheap a mulch you can get.
– High organic matter and really quick breakdown.
– Can clump up over the top of your soil and stop moisture penetration.
– Gets pretty smelly as it decomposes.
– Can contain weed and grass seeds that will germinate in the garden.
– Has next to no visual appeal.
– Because it’s so abundant, people over apply it and it’s easy to get too much mixed through the soil.
Fallen leaves from trees. Can be from normal year round leaf drop, but mostly from deciduous trees in Autumn.
– A great way to use up all those fallen leaves in Autumn.
– Using native leaf little around native plants in a great way to mimic natural processes.
– Breaks down quick and is great for microorganisms.
– Clump together when wet and can get slippery and then dry solid.
– Not very long lasting, and isn’t really available outside of Autumn.
– very little visual appeal.
Can include a variety of different sized granules, colours and the way you present it.
– Will cover an area for a long time.
– Allows water to penetrate through to the soil easily.
– Can look amazing in the right context.
– Can mix with dirt and begin to look really shabby.
– Really hard to remove if you change your mind.
– Limits any planting changes you may want down the track.
– Plenty of area for weeds to grow in.
Covers a huge range of different colours, and granule size. Can include loose stones thrown into an area, or decomposed granite or rhyolite that contain a binding agent.
– Can look really good in a big open area.
– Almost guarantees no weed growth.
– A long term option.
– Once it is in, it’s there for good.
– Not much hope for surrounding shrubs or food crops.
– Not a great option for in and around gardens.
Treated Wood Chips.
Treated pine or hardwood timber chips that provide the same visuals as mulch, but take much longer to break down. Often also treated with a coloured dye.
– Offers a range of colours to compliment or contrast within the landscape.
– Extremely long lasting, meaning top ups are less often.
– Easily available from nearly every nursery supply store, and often in small easy to transport quantities.
– Full of chemicals that will leach into your soil.
– Dyes aren’t as long lasting as wood chips, so they become faded and dull before they breakdown.
– Because they don’t break down easily, they are tough to get out of an area if you change your mind.
Fancy taking this info with you into the garden? Download this guide as a printable cheat sheet! agt-mulching-cheat-sheet